Monday, April 15, 2024

Electric travel guitar shootout: Traveler Ultralight vs Traveler EG-1 Matte vs Donner Hush-X vs Steinberger/Spirit GT-Pro

I can't find any direct comparison of the three electric travel guitars I am most interested in, and since they might be the three YOU are most interested in, too, I figure I'll take some notes as I go.

I've been using the Traveler ultra-light, including 3 weeks across spain and france by train and plane, for a couple years, but on my last trip I was frustrated enough with its limitations that I figuired I'd gotten my money's worth from it and was ready to upgrade.

The things I liked: 

  • light weight, easy to sling the bag over my shoulder or put it in the side straps of my soft-sided carryon bag
  • gig bag pocket has room for a Spark Go, cable, wired headphones (Grado SR-80), picks, tuner, and slide
  • little leg stand made it at least somewhat lap-playable
Things I didn't like:
  • tone: no volume, no tone knob - ok for turned down rhythm but brutal for lead - very harsh, wanted to roll off but couldn't 
  • access up the neck - although there's lots of frets, the body starts coming out from the neck above where it ends and that's harder to reach - tuning stability - it was getting to where it wouldn't stay in tune for the length of an entire song 
  • only one bridge pickup - again, no options for tone. Just that one shrill tone. 

 I'm evaluating: 

  • Traveler EG-1 - mini Les Paul style. $499.
  • Donner Hush-X - similar to the Ultralight, but with a top brace as well as a bottom one. I put it in my Amazon cart at $349, and then later that day they had a flash deal for about $300.
  • Steinberger/Spirit GT-Pro - Gibson seems to own the brand now; this is a reboot of the Steinberger design. They did get Steinberger himself to make a promo video for the GT-Pro at least. 

I can't find any of these locally, so I'm going to take advantage of Amazon's return policy - including local drop-offs so I don't pay anything for return shipping - to test out all three and decide which one I'll take on my upcoming travels, including a cross-country road-trip.

Right now my expectations are: 

The Traveler: will be pretty solid, it's a front-runner; it's basically what I'm used to, minimally larger, with better pickup, volume and tone knob. Sounds like a conservative winner. But it is also the most expensive. 

The Donner. As their 2nd gen product it sounds like they had some good design feedback and improvement over the Hush-I - it may be as much on target as the EG-1. I'm not sure if it'll be as compact as the EG1, especially in its bag. I do like the separate pickups, good chance of tonal range, especially vs the EG-1 single humbucker 

The GT-Pro is a wide open Q. I've seen some youtube reports of awful QC, not sure if the one I get is MI China or Indonesia, guess we'll find out. Also unsure if the pickups are any good, will the tremelo be decent? it's not the legenendray harm-trem of the OG steinbergers. But, it's actrually designed as a full-fledged guitar that just happens to be stripped down to what is optimal for travel -0 not a purpose-built travel guitar. So, perhaps it's a whole nother level of travel guitar "real tone" and "real feel" 

I expewct all of these have fairly entry level pickups, I'm just hoping not actively BAD pickups. But I do have a SD JB bridge pickup that I got to put into a 3/4 scale cheap guitar, just to practice soldering before risking upgrading the pickups on my telecaster; I figure there's a good chancve I'll end up swappoing the JB into whatever I get - I saw several reviewers say they did similar upgrades, including even that exact bridge P/U, on these guitars and good results.

First one should arrive tomorrow, we'll see!

3 comments:

  1. How’d you go with the comparison of all 3? I’ve been looking at the Hush X and Spirit lately.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So, if you have any electrical needs, don't hesitate to call a professional.Power Route Electric

    ReplyDelete
  3. Because of NiCd battery memory effect, if not fully discharged, should be in charge before each battery discharge to 1V below.Custom Lithium Battery Pack Manufacturer

    ReplyDelete